You know, I have never been able to get into James/Scorpius. I think because James/Teddy is my next gen OTP, and my James just refuses to be with anybody but Teddy.

I haven't read much AS/S, but I liked: Seeing Is Believing, which you might have read, because it's also H/D. And The Summer Al Began Tried to Live, which is a non-magic AU. Asshole!James, which isn't my favorite, but I liked the story. :D